For f(x) ∈ ℤ[x] and a ∈ ℤ, we let fn(x) be the nth iterate of f(x), P(f, a) = {p prime: p|fn(a) for some n}, and D(P(f, a)) denote the natural density of P(f, a) within the set of primes. A conjecture of Jones [5] indicates that D(P(f, a)) = 0 for most quadratic f. In this paper, we find an exceptional family of (f, a) such that D(P(f, a)) > 0 by considering ft(x) = (x + t)2 - 2 - t and at = ft(0) for t ∈ ℤ. We prove that if t is not of the form ±M2 ± 2 or ±2M2 ± 2, then D(P(ft, at)) = ⅓. We also determine D(P(ft, at)) in some cases when the density is not equal to ⅓. Our results suggest a connection between the arithmetic dynamics of the conjugates of x2 and the conjugates of x2 - 2.