One-rank perturbations of Wigner matrices have been closely studied: let P=1√nA+𝜃vvT with A=(aij)1≤i,j≤n∈ℝn×n symmetric, (aij)1≤i≤j≤n i.i.d. with centered standard normal distributions, and 𝜃>0,v∈𝕊n−1. It is well known λ1(P), the largest eigenvalue of P, has a phase transition at 𝜃0=1: when 𝜃≤1,λ1(P)a.s.→2, whereas for 𝜃>1,λ1(P)a.s.→𝜃+𝜃−1. Under more general conditions, the limiting behavior of λ1(P), appropriately normalized, has also been established: it is normal if ||v||∞=o(1), or the convolution of the law of a11 and a Gaussian distribution if v is concentrated on one entry. These convergences require a finite fourth moment, and this paper considers situations violating this condition. For symmetric distributions a11, heavy-tailed with index α∈(0,4), the fluctuations are shown to be universal and dependent on 𝜃 but not on v, whereas a subfamily of the edge case α=4 displays features of both the light- and heavy-tailed regimes: two limiting laws emerge and depend on whether v is localized, each presenting a continuous phase transition at 𝜃0=1,𝜃0∈[1,12889], respectively. These results build on our previous work which analyzes the asymptotic behavior of λ1(1√nA) in the aforementioned subfamily.