Let RR be a ring with identity. The unit (respectively, unitary Cayley) graph of RR is a simple graph G(R)G(R) (respectively, Γ(R)Γ(R)) with vertex set RR, where two distinct vertices xx and yy are adjacent if and only if x+yx+y (respectively, x−yx−y) is a unit of RR. In this paper, we explore when G(R)G(R) and Γ(R)Γ(R) are isomorphic for a finite ring RR. Among other results, we prove that G(R)G(R) is isomorphic to Γ(R)Γ(R) for a finite ring RR if and only if char(R/J(R)R/J(R))=2 or R/J(R)≅ℤ2×S, where J(R) is the Jacobson radical of R and S is a finite ring.